Colour values change on their own! Very frustrating
Colours keep slightly changing over time, even as I am designing live inside a file!
I will enter an exact CMYK or RGB value to match our brands colours, then these values will change slightly all on their own.
I've been monitoring this for about 2 months now hoping this issue would be resolved in an update... but it hasnt been!
This is a massive issue! Colours have to be stable!
We need to be able to trust the program with things that are vital for a brand, like their COLOURS!
The attached image shows -
Top: is the original version of the design with correct colour values
Bottom: shows the change in colour and colour values a few mins later (still live in file, no save/close)
Same issue. Trying Affinity now. I am so so so DONE with this :-/
Im so over this issue... continues to happen and even gets worse.
20years on Ai this has never been an issue, but now it is.
Please dont tel me its my colour profile or I might explode.
FUKN FIX THIS ADOBE!!!!!
No, colour change only happens in Ai
Im seeing very noticeable changes happening more quickly now too... It seems to affect light and dark colours more dramatically.
Yes its not acceptable to have a major problem like this exist in Ai, especially as you pay top dollar for it.
Ive contacted Adobe directly and posted comments here and other places.. yet Adobe ignore this issue.
I'm now just adapting and getting used to having to adjust ALL COLOURS in Ai documents before exporting finished art - So frerakin annoying!!!!!
J Hamilton commented
Do you see this slight color change anywhere else? Example; I'm working on adjusting colors on a CMYK document to get them as close as possible to a separate RGB document. We use a third party color picker to get the color value off the original RGB, and then when we put that into Illustrator CMYK, AI then displays a noticeably different color (not the typical RGB -> CMYK shift) and different number color values. We've spent hours going over the color profiles within AI and matching them between all the programs and other management settings that might be contributing. We only see this inconsistency with AI, very frustrating to type in a CMYK value, and then have it change it the values. We now have to sit and play the toggle game on the palette sliders to correct it. I'm willing to be told I'm totally missing something, but colors changing unexpectedly is a major problem for software like this...
Looks very frustrating :( Does it happen in one particular file only or across several docs?
Have you tried to move one colored to a different file and see how it behaves there?
Does it occur in new docs too?
Can you share the file for everybody and the team to test?
Also - I'm not copy pasting between CMYK / RGB files.
This colour change is happening to elements that never leave the file / colour profile they were created in.
Yes, Ive never seen this happen before either - 20+ years using Adobe
Yes, colours change live while working on a file. I tested this by checking a colour breakdown.. continued to design in the file without closing.. then going back to check colour breakdown about 30 mins later. So weird.
To add to this - Working on a file, save close. reopen file and work, colours change again, save close. Ive had elements sitting off to the side of a document that I havnt touched in weeks/months and you can see a massive change over time to the colours of these elements. Its like every time I open the file the colours change slightly, and aginf the next open, and again.. till its radically diferent. See attached img, this element has been sitting on the side of my document for the last 6 weeks, look at the change in colour.
I've never seen this happen in a live file without copying or changing color modes, so I'm actually curious to how this happening to you while only working on a live file. Does this happen if you make the color a swatch or is it only when you pick a from the color picker?
Just a guess as to what might be happening. I noticed you are working in RGB and CMYK color spaces between documents. If you happen to switch between RGB and CMYK documents it will change the color values as CMYK has a smaller color gamut. Meaning if you select an RGB value and then switch to a CMYK document or copy to it then it will convert it to CMYK values within its gamut as it can't technically show those RGB values in CMYK.