Alessandro Gritta
My feedback
2 results found
-
41 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment Alessandro Gritta supported this idea ·
-
12 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment Alessandro Gritta commented
I've noticed a potentially dangerous behavior in Adobe Illustrator that I believe should be reconsidered, especially for professional print production workflows.
When an object has Overprint Fill or Overprint Stroke enabled, changing its color to white does not automatically disable the overprint attribute.
This seems inconsistent with Illustrator's own warning system, which alerts users when they attempt to apply overprint directly to a white object.
In other words, Illustrator recognizes that white overprint can cause printing problems, yet allows the same potentially dangerous condition to occur silently when an existing overprinted object is recolored to white.
I'm aware that Illustrator includes the "Discard White Overprint" option to prevent issues during output. However, this does not address the underlying behavior within the original document.
My suggestion:
When an object's fill or stroke is changed to standard process white (CMYK 0/0/0/0), Illustrator should automatically disable the corresponding overprint attribute.
Alternatively, Illustrator should at least display a clear warning, allowing the user to decide whether to keep or remove the overprint setting.
Intentional overprinting of special spot colors, such as opaque white ink, should remain unaffected.
This improvement would help prevent production errors, reduce the need for manual checks, and make Illustrator's behavior more consistent with its own overprint warnings.
For a professional application widely used in packaging, prepress, and print production, I believe this would be a valuable improvement.
Alessandro Gritta supported this idea ·
I would like to report a frustrating behavior in Adobe Illustrator when using the Rotate View feature together with the Move command (Object > Transform > Move).
When I rotate the canvas view, for example by 90° or 180°, the Move dialog still calculates horizontal and vertical movements according to the original document orientation, rather than the current visual orientation of the canvas.
As a result, if I want to move an object to the left or right as I see it on my screen, I have to mentally calculate how the original document axes are oriented.
This becomes particularly frustrating when working on complex layouts, packaging designs, or artwork that requires frequent canvas rotation and precise object positioning.
My suggestion:
The Move dialog should offer an option to calculate horizontal and vertical movements relative to the current rotated canvas view.
Ideally, users could choose between:
- Document coordinates: movements follow the original document axes, as they do now.
- View coordinates: movements follow the current visual orientation of the canvas, regardless of its rotation.
The same principle should ideally apply to keyboard arrow movements and alignment commands.
I understand why Illustrator maintains the original document coordinate system internally. However, when working with a rotated view, I believe that precise positioning should also be possible from the user's visual perspective.
This would make the Rotate View feature much more intuitive and useful in professional design workflows.