stefaan van damme
My feedback
2 results found
-
2 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment
stefaan van damme
shared this idea
·
-
4 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment
stefaan van damme
commented
Thanks @Egor for the thoughtful reply and the references — they’re very helpful.
I agree that Illustrator is not a CAD application, and that CAD software is often better suited to interpret Bézier geometry and convert it into true arcs. In practice, CAD-side conversion options like the ones you linked are indeed the most realistic solution today.
That said, I still hope this conversation can live on as a forward-looking consideration rather than a closed conclusion.
Illustrator does provide the data it has — Bézier curves — but in many real-world workflows those curves originate from exact primitives and constrained constructions. Once that semantic information is discarded, the handoff becomes lossy in a way that isn’t always visible to users until fabrication.
Even if the primary responsibility remains on the CAD side, any future improvement in how Illustrator preserves, exposes, or flags known constant-radius geometry before export would be greatly appreciated. Not as an attempt to turn Illustrator into CAD, but as a way to make the transition between design and fabrication more transparent and intentional.
For those of us using Illustrator as an early step in automated or CNC-oriented workflows, small improvements in this area would have a disproportionately positive impact.
Thanks again for engaging with the topic — even acknowledging these edge cases already helps move the conversation forward.
stefaan van damme
shared this idea
·
Hey @Egor,
This isn’t meant to be a duplicate in terms of intent.
I initially posted this as a feature request, but after further discussion and testing I’ve come to the conclusion that it fits better under bugs, as it concerns silent degradation of exported data rather than missing functionality.
If you feel this should live in one place, I’m happy to keep only the most appropriate entry.
Thanks for checking!