We need the option to set the RGB workspace to always use HSB sliders. In my ideal workspace, I would never ever see an RGB slider.

Yeah, a general switch, I get it. Still a new thing :)

Different wording is a problem, but that’s how language works. Requests and reports get merged not by similar wording, but by content similarity.

'Magic wand' can be a word that cause problems. Auto-ban system never worked in Ai :)

Hey, Keith, you are correct, there are plenty of HSB-related requests, and that request you shared has the same reason underneath.

Funny that you added your vote to it, but created another one that blurs that votes further, according to you :)

Do not worry! The team tries to track and merge similar requests (those about Magic Wand you voted for got merged too).

However, this request of yours, while being about HSB as well, won’t be merged — because you decided to keep it separate from the major one and specifically described the reason, 'get rid of RGB'. The 87-votes one is about one specific issue, that is smaller than your request — and that’s why that request can’t be merged with this one.

But notes are taken. Thanks!

スウォッチオプションでカラーを変更するときが問題です。

カラーバーがRGBになっているので
カラーモードをHSBにするがRBGのままです。
一度、CMYKなどにしてからHSBに設定すると
カラーバーもHSBになります。

Adobe Illustrator 2021（ いつも最新版です。）
mac OS 10.15.7

たとえば、最初からカラーを取り扱う設定を決められれば良いと思います。

新規ドキュメント　詳細でカラーモードを設定するときに、CMYK、RGB、HSBと選べればいいと思います。
HSBはRGBではありますが。。。
とにかくHSB固定にして欲しい。

最近、この問題起こっています。終わりにしないでください！再現したらまたコメントします！

Been happening to me consistently for a couple years.

Makes using HSB ridiculous. What do you mean you can't reproduce the issue inhouse? Then go to ANY cafe, someone will have their laptop with Illustrator. Borrow it and you will see. Please fix this!

Using Swatch Options is a real pain.
I like to work in HSB, but the palette switches to RGB all the time (while the drop down is still on HSB).
And, secondly, it forgets that I like to have the Preview on - why shouldn't anyone don't like to? Please let it remember the user's choices. Thanks!

See movie for the struggle.

こちら新たな情報がありませんので、対応終了とさせていただきます。
もし、追加情報があるようでしたら、コメント可能な状態にしておきますので、ご投稿ください。

今後ともよろしくお願いいたします。

Illustrator チーム

This happens to me, too. And it is tedious when changing a lot of global swatches.

To reproduce, double click a swatch change the color mode to HSB. Click OK. Double click that swatch or another swatch again. It will show a color mode of HSB but the sliders are RGB.

Currently I'm using Windows 10.0.19042
AI version 25.4.1 64-bit

Here is a video of the problem

Here is a video of the problem

Still happening on Illustrator 25.3.1....

Seems to have to do with the order things are managed in the code of Ai.

(See my request about the New Document dialog, where something alike happens).

Same for me - had this issue for about 6 months

カラーモードHSBで作業している。カラーの変更をするために、その下のカラーバーで変更しようとするがRGBのまま。
いちいちRGBにしてからまたHSBに変更するとHSBになる。
カラーモードの固定をお願いします。
以前はこのようなバグはありませんでした。

When I double-click a swatch colour that was made in HSB mode the Swatch Options window pops up with HSB selected as the mode but displays sliders for RGB. Switching the mode to something else and back to HSB fixes the issue.

When switching to HSB, the RGB sliders remain.

Illustrator CC2021 (v25.1)

In a RGB document, create a new Swatch Color:

Swatch Options: “Process Color”, “Global”, “Color Mode: HSB”

Define your color (using HSB sliders) and swatch name. Press OK.

Double click again on that color, and here comes the PROBLEM:

You can see the “Color Mode: HSB”

BUT

Your color sliders are for R,G,B not for H,S,B (!!!)

To edit your color as HSB you need to change “Color Mode: RGB” and again “Color Mode: HSB”

Imagine this issue editing dozens of colors…

After defining a global color if you double-click it to redefine it, the panel displays RGB sliders even though I had previously selected HSB. The Color Mode drop-down menu displays "HSB" but the controls/sliders are for RGB. The only way to edit the color correctly is for me to change the drop-down value to something else, then back to HSB.