Brush Pressure exceeds set size/variation
When drawing with the brush in CC 2018, the brush size of the stroke can exceed the set size and variation. For instance, If I have a brush size of 3 and variation 3, when drawing pressing very hard, the stroke size will go above 3 pts. in CC 2017 the brush stroke was limited to brush size.
Hi, all.
As per the investigation done by the engineering team, the issue is not a bug, but an expected scenario.
Variation means that it should go both above and below the set size.
So a 3pt stroke with 3pt variation will draw from 0 to 6 pt. Kindly reach out to us incase you have any queries.
Regards, Aishwarya G Gadodia
Illustrator Team
-
Tim Iland commented
we need this fixed, it's a big issue for my work now that I'm using a surface
-
Filip commented
This is absolutely a bug and not an expected scenario. It works flawlessly on all other devices and only happens on the Surface Pro 7. Please view my previous comments for more details, I event sent a video to your team to help you fix the buggy issue.....
-
Mark Nicoll commented
Aishwarya, it may be an "expected scenario" to developers who understand the local implimentation logic, but when it's not expected by your users there could be a UX issue worth unpacking.
From what people are saying, it seems like they (and I) are expecting brush pressure controls and behaviour that are roughly consistent with Photoshop.
In Photoshop:
- brush size, as previewed with the cursor, is its maxiumum (100%) value
- by default pressure affects size all the way down to 0%
- a 'Minimum Diameter' can be specified as a percentage of the current brush size.This is a far more intuitive, usable implimentation than our current "expected scenario" in Illustrator.
-
Filip commented
This is a bug that's been present for years with all Surface users and there is still no fix for it. I can't get tapered ends on my lines using Adobe Illustrator no matter what I do. (See attached file for more details). The line outside of the box is an example of what I should be getting, the lines inside the box are what I am getting. This issue happens with 100% of Adobe Illustrator that are on the Surface Pro. This has been a problem for years and it has been ignored even after multiple reports throughout the years so I posted on the Surface subreddit and all of the people who tested it have the same issue. I know that this is not how it's supposed to work and it's only a problem with Adobe Illustrator (Tested: Clip Paint Studio, Photoshop, Affinity Designer and all work perfect). I bought my Surface specifically to be able to use Adobe Illustrator on the go, as I suppose many other artists did as well. Multiple users that use Adobe Illustrator have reported this issue and there still hasn't been a fix since 2017 and it's like this for all Surface devices. Sucks for the Surface users and artists that use Illustrator as their main software.
-
Filip commented
This is awful. 2020 and still no fix, I bought a Surface 7 pro to be able to use Illustrator on the go but it's unusable like this!
-
ktotheb commented
any update?
-
ktotheb commented
Windows 10, fall creators update, stable build
-
Amitesh Srivastava commented
Sorry for troubling you again, but OS and version, would also help.
-
ktotheb commented
Here's a video:
https://youtu.be/CzCb4gyvVw4I create new document.
draw a line with line tool at 5pts.
then draw with brush at 5pts fixed.
then change brush to pressure 5 pt variation.
then draw and you can it is thicker than 5 pt line.
also, brush strokes don't show pressure in real time, only after finished.
only when i click on another tool, and then back on brush, does it reflect brush pressure in real time. -
Amitesh Srivastava commented
Hi Ktoheb, can you please share a video for it, Thanks.
-
ktotheb commented
When drawing with the brush in CC 2018, the brush size of the stroke can exceed the set size and variation. For instance, If I have a brush size of 3 and variation 3, when drawing pressing very hard, the stroke size will go above 3 pts. in CC 2017 the brush stroke was limited to brush size.