Brush strokes get displaced from their paths in large canvas documents
I found a bug that affects the placement of stroke art in relation to its stroke path. When creating a document that needs a canvas that's larger than 227" it results in paths being offset from their original path without any additional effects. When creating a document that has a 227" canvas the stroke art is correctly aligned to their path.
-
Screen Shot 2022-12-08 at 12.11.30 PM.png 80 KB -
Screenshot 2021-03-29 at 20.17.51.png 164 KB -
Large Canvas Art Brush.ai 97 KB -
Screenshot 2020-11-17 at 10.17.43.png 290 KB -
Screenshot 2020-11-17 at 10.17.43.png 290 KB -
Screen Shot 2020-10-22 at 10.55.36 AM.png 297 KB -
Screen Shot 2020-10-22 at 10.55.36 AM.png 297 KB
Nate
shared this idea
-
Ten_A
commented
me too!
-
CLS
commented
Still happening on large size documents in 28.6.
-
Cynthia Camauer commented
Still wrong on 28.2
-
Katarina Jovanovic commented
Still happening in 28.0
-
Alyson Herzog commented
Still having this error on an oversized artboard using charcoal brushes 5/26/2023
-
ciana coin commented
Here is my working environment.
Illustrator 27.3.1iMac (latest OS)
3.6 GHz 10-core Intel Core i9
AMD Radeon Pro 5700 XT 16 GB
128 GB 2667 MHz DDR4 -
Copy and paste to normal canvas will fix the misalignment.
Copy and paste the corrected path to the larger canvas and the misalignment will be restored. -
This happens with large document sizes.
Please see the screen capture video I recorded.
I hope it will be resolved. -
Ton commented
This happens with large document sizes.
-
However, I can’t confirm this problem to not exist in versions prior to 2023.
26.5.2 shows the same behaviour.Upon investigation, I see that the brush you are using is a giant path, 98.0938 inches long and 5.3154 inches tall, in the document’s units.
However, the scale option chosen for the art brush is 'Stretch to Fit Stroke Length'. So it means that Illustrator should maintain the 5.3154 height of it (that it a width or 'weight' of the stroke) across the line, which is not the case nor in 2022, neither in 2023 versions!
If we rebuild the same giant brush in an much older version, such as CS6, Illustrator maintains the original height of the artwork used — as intended.
So it’s not 2023 got broken, but 2022 before it!This needs further investigation.
Meanwhile — what was the latest version you say you were able to use this specific 'fat brush' succefully? Are you sure in that? It can’t be 2022. -
DG, thanks for the file.
I confirm this issue. -
DG commented
Here's a sample file demonstrating the issue @Egor
-
Custom art brush offsets when you select and redraw the path using brush tool. Bottom path is redrawn.
-
Everett Bloom commented
This happened to me today.
-
Darryl Blake
commented
Still a issue as of today's date. 2022-04-11
-
Wayne Shinn
commented
It is still a issue with Brush offset from the line on a large canvas
-
Tommy
commented
This is still an issue.
-
Gerhard Smith
commented
This error has not been fixed yet.
-
Graham
commented
Still a problem
-
Rico Worl
commented
Still not fixxed >.<
same problem.
